A Utah court has issued a comprehensive order outlining specific parameters for media access and remote participation in an upcoming trial-setting hearing. Judge Tony Graf’s ruling, dated October 2, 2026, dictates the terms for the October 23, 2026, session in the case against Tyler Robinson, who is charged with the 2025 killing of Charlie Kirk.
The order confirms that a still photographer from Deseret News will be granted access to the proceeding. This approval carries forward a previous ruling, docketed as number 756, which initially authorized still photography. Judge Graf reiterated this permission, stating that the earlier order “is CONFIRMED for the October 23, 2026 trial-setting hearing, subject to the existing requirements identified below.”
However, the ruling places strict limitations on other forms of media coverage. Judge Graf explicitly stated that no media video or audio coverage was requested or is authorized by the current order. While court-provided remote access is permitted under paragraph seven of the order, this authorization comes with its own set of restrictions. Paragraph seven specifies that "This remote-access authorization does not permit media broadcasting or recording."
Remote access to the hearing has been granted to specific individuals. Burt and Erika Kirk, or Erika Kirk's attorney, have the option to attend the hearing remotely. The court will facilitate this remote connection using a "Judicial Council-approved platform," providing connection information ahead of the session. The order also addresses potential technical difficulties, stipulating that "Before deciding a matter requiring Mr. Burt’s participation or implicating an applicable victim’s right to be heard, the court shall address any reported connection failure on the record and determine an appropriate means of proceeding.” This provision ensures that critical decisions are not made if a participant's connection is compromised, particularly concerning victims' rights.
The upcoming October 23, 2026, session marks the first court appearance in the Robinson case since Judge Graf’s significant ruling on September 1. On that date, Graf found that prosecutors had established probable cause, the necessary legal standard for a case to advance toward trial. Following this finding, Tyler Robinson entered a plea of not guilty to all counts related to Charlie Kirk's death. The primary purpose of the forthcoming hearing is to establish a trial date for Robinson.
This judicial order highlights the court's efforts to balance public transparency, judicial decorum, and the rights of all parties involved, including the accused and victims. By allowing still photography, the court provides some visual access to the proceedings, while prohibiting video and audio broadcasting maintains control over the courtroom environment and potentially sensitive testimony. The provision for remote attendance for key individuals also reflects an adaptation to modern communication methods within the judicial process, ensuring their participation without requiring physical presence. As Robinson returns to court, the established rules will govern the conduct and access surrounding this critical phase of the legal process.
