President Donald Trump has reportedly focused on the physical appearance of former Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton when discussing a significant Republican defeat in the state's recent Senate election. According to a report from the Daily Mail, President Trump privately questioned whether Paxton's drooping right eyelid contributed to his loss against Democrat James Talarico. This electoral outcome handed Democrats their first Texas Senate victory since 1988, marking a dramatic shift in a state that has consistently supported Republican presidential nominees since 1980.
"What’s up with that eye of his" President Donald Trump, Reportedly in the Oval Office
The November midterm election saw Paxton defeated by approximately 12 percentage points. Following the election, President Trump reportedly raised the issue of Paxton's eye during conversations in the Oval Office. "What's up with that eye of his," President Trump allegedly asked, according to the Daily Mail report. He reportedly continued to raise the subject with White House aides, even suggesting a physician he knows in Florida could address the condition. "I mean wouldn’t you get that fixed?" the president reportedly inquired. Two additional sources reportedly confirmed that President Trump made similar remarks in separate discussions. The Daily Mail's account has not been independently verified, and President Trump has not publicly attributed Paxton's appearance as a reason for his electoral defeat.
Ken Paxton, 63, has a history of injuries to his right eye. At age 12, he sustained a serious injury when struck by chinaberries thrown by other children, requiring nearly two weeks of hospitalization and five surgeries. Years later, during a college basketball game at Baylor University, an elbow further damaged the bones surrounding the same eye. A campaign insider reportedly claimed that Paxton's eye injury had become a recurring topic among his staff, who allegedly made unflattering jokes about his appearance.
The reported remarks by President Trump emerge amidst broader Republican introspection regarding the party's unexpected loss of a Senate seat in a state long considered a Republican stronghold. Paxton's 12-point defeat represents a significant swing of nearly 26 percentage points compared to President Trump's 2024 presidential victory in Texas. This result has intensified criticism of President Trump's decision to endorse Paxton over the incumbent Republican Senator, John Cornyn. President Trump endorsed Paxton on May 19, citing Cornyn's previous public criticism of his political leadership in 2023 as a factor in his decision.
The endorsement process itself was not without internal contention. The Daily Mail reported that Trump adviser Natalie Harp frequently presented the president with articles critical of Senator Cornyn. Former Trump fundraising official Caroline Wren was also reportedly involved in forwarding such information to Harp. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins has faced questions regarding her influence on the endorsement. Matt Mackowiak, a former senior adviser to Cornyn’s campaign, contended that Rollins played a significant role in persuading President Trump not to support the incumbent senator. However, White House insiders disputed this characterization, acknowledging Rollins' support for Paxton but denying she was solely responsible for President Trump's decision. A source close to Rollins stated that she maintained a 25-year friendship and political alliance with Paxton but was not asked to weigh in on the endorsement. These conflicting accounts highlight the internal disagreements among Republicans following the costly defeat.
Paxton entered the election burdened by considerable political challenges. He had been impeached by the Texas House over allegations of abuse of office, though the state Senate acquitted him in 2023. His personal life also became a campaign issue. His marriage to state Senator Angela Paxton concluded after she filed for divorce in July 2025, citing adultery, with the divorce finalized on November 11, days after the election. Additional reports regarding Paxton's relationship with Christian influencer Tracy Duhon further fueled controversy during the campaign.
Despite these factors, Republican organizations collectively spent over $281 million on advertising in an unsuccessful effort to retain the Texas Senate seat. The electoral setbacks extended beyond Paxton's race, with Democrats also securing other statewide offices, prompting questions about the GOP's long-term competitiveness in Texas. The implications of these losses are substantial for Republicans as they look toward the 2028 presidential election, given Texas's 40 electoral votes. For President Trump and his advisers, the immediate challenge involves comprehending how Republicans incurred such significant losses in a state that has historically been a reliable electoral stronghold. While some party insiders have attributed the defeat to Paxton's scandals, campaign strategy, or President Trump's endorsement decision, the Daily Mail's account suggests President Trump has repeatedly focused on the candidate's physical appearance. The ongoing debate over the endorsement's origins and the reasons for the defeat continues to generate tension among Republicans as they strategize for future elections.