WASHINGTON – The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal from a California ophthalmologist challenging a state rule that dictates specific content for continuing medical education courses. The decision leaves intact a Ninth Circuit ruling upholding California’s requirement that such courses, particularly those involving direct patient care, include a discussion of implicit bias in medical treatment. Justice Clarence Thomas filed a dissent from the Court’s decision to deny certiorari, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, arguing that the case presented important constitutional questions concerning compelled speech.
"The First Amendment generally prohibits the government from telling people what they must say." Justice Clarence Thomas, U.S. Supreme Court
Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, who teaches courses physicians must complete to maintain their medical licenses, brought the challenge. California law directs these courses to address issues such as how unconscious attitudes can affect medical decisions. Dr. Khatibi contended that this mandate violated her First Amendment rights by compelling her to communicate the state’s preferred viewpoint, which she stated she does not share. She argued that the state could achieve its goals through other means, such as providing its own implicit-bias training or requiring doctors to receive separate instruction, without forcing private educators to deliver the message.
California adopted the implicit bias requirement as part of a broader effort to address alleged disparities in healthcare outcomes among various racial and demographic groups. Supporters of the rule maintain that implicit bias can influence treatment decisions even when healthcare professionals harbor no conscious intent to treat patients differently. They contend that acknowledging and addressing these biases is crucial for ensuring equitable patient care and improving public health.
The lower courts did not side with Dr. Khatibi. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that California was within its rights to impose content requirements on these courses, reasoning that they serve a professional licensing function that the state legitimately regulates. This professional licensing context, the court suggested, grants the state more leeway in dictating curriculum content. Following this adverse ruling, Dr. Khatibi petitioned the nation's highest court for review. As is customary when the Supreme Court declines a case, the justices did not provide a reason for their decision.
However, Justice Thomas offered a detailed explanation for his dissent. He emphasized that the dispute raises fundamental constitutional questions about the limits of government power in dictating what private speakers must say. His opinion began by establishing a clear principle for such situations: “When, as here, the government does not issue its own messages but instead requires private speakers to communicate the government’s viewpoint, the First Amendment applies.”
Thomas directly challenged the state’s position, asserting that California cannot circumvent First Amendment scrutiny by framing such mandates as professional regulation. “A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny. We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as ‘a cover for censorship’ or a cloak for compelled speech,” he wrote. He underscored the broad constitutional principle that “The First Amendment generally prohibits the government from telling people what they must say.”
Justice Thomas further warned of the potential for such governmental mandates to extend beyond the medical field. He articulated concerns that allowing governments to require private instructors to communicate state-selected ideas could set a dangerous precedent. “If California can force a doctor to convey the State’s preferred message in a continuing medical education course, there is little reason why it could not force other professionals to do the same,” Thomas stated in his dissent.
He highlighted that the constitutional problem becomes particularly acute when a government compels a private speaker to present contested ideas, as opposed to merely disclosing factual information. Thomas also reiterated that a state cannot evade First Amendment scrutiny simply because the compelled speech occurs in a professional or educational setting. He summarized this point concisely: “Private citizens do not become government mouthpieces simply because they teach a state-mandated course.”
The case touches upon a recurring legal tension between government regulation of professional conduct and constitutionally protected compelled speech. Thomas cited the Court's 2018 decision in *National Institute of Family and Life Advocates v. Becerra*, where the Supreme Court struck down portions of a California law that required pregnancy centers to provide certain government-mandated notices. In that ruling, the Court rejected the notion that "professional speech" constitutes a distinct category entitled to reduced First Amendment protection. Justice Thomas argued that these principles should have guided the Court’s review of Dr. Khatibi’s challenge.